An absurd comparison, on purpose. For what most American families pay for assisted living, you could literally buy a brand-new 911 every year. Or — and this is the actual point — you could renovate the house once and keep her in it for a decade.
The 2026 Porsche 911 Carrera starts around $122,000. The 2026 national average for assisted living is around $5,500 a month, or $66,000 a year. In a high-cost state, you're closer to $8,500/month, or $102,000 a year.
A serious universal-design renovation — zero-step entry, walk-in shower with grab bars, widened doorways, lever handles, better lighting, a stair lift, smart smoke detectors and motion sensors, a first-floor sleeping setup — runs $25,000 to $80,000 for a typical home. AARP says about $50,000 is a reasonable midpoint. And here's the thing nobody tells you: that money goes into the house. It comes back out when you sell. Assisted living comes back out as memories.
Assisted living is a recurring expense. Every month, the bill arrives. Every year, the bill goes up roughly 4-6% — faster than general inflation in most years. There's no asset at the end. The check just gets cashed.
A renovation is a one-time expense that increases the value of the asset you already own. Universal-design upgrades typically return 50-70% of their cost in resale value (per Remodeling Magazine's annual Cost vs Value report and AARP HomeFit research), and they let her stay in the house another five, eight, ten years if cognition stays stable.
It only works if she can be safe at home with the right setup. Universal design helps with mobility, falls, and accessibility. It does not solve dementia. It does not solve the need for 24-hour supervision. It does not solve loneliness. The day she needs more than the renovation can provide, you're paying for the renovation and the facility — and that's where families get into trouble.
The honest framework: if cognition is stable and the body is the issue, renovate. If cognition is sliding, plan for the move and don't sink $50k into a house she'll be leaving.
Because the comparison makes a real point. Most American families think assisted living is "expensive but normal." It is not normal. It is one of the largest discretionary expenses any household will ever take on. Treating it that way — instead of as a default — opens up the real menu of options. The renovation. The stair lift. The home aide three days a week. The sale of the house and a downsizing move. The CCRC entry fee. They're all on the table, and most families never run the numbers.
Also, if she actually wants the Porsche, get her the Porsche.
Palmelle's advisors don't sell facilities, contractors, or cars. They help you figure out which road is actually right.
Get a real opinion